G. W. says: "Please tell ua whether you meant to say in September number of Gardener's Monthly that the Hame's apple, or Hagloe, is a month later than Red Astrachan. Grammatically it is Hagloe; but Elliott says the Hagloe is a month earlier. We have an apple which resembles 20 ounce pippin, and is known as Pennington Red Astrachan, but has been pronounced by Dr. Warder to be Hagloe, although it is a month later than Red Astrachan. Who is right?"

[We meant as it reads, that Hagloe is later. If we are not correct in this, we shall be glad to be corrected by those who have the kinds to gether. - Ed. G. M.]