13 First National Bank v. Kirkby, 43 Fla. 376; 32 So. 881.

14 Kirby v. Scraper Co., 9 S. D. 623; 70 N. W. 1052.

15 Mcintosh-Huntington Co. v. Rice, 13 Colo. App. 393; 58 Pac. 358; Finance Co. v. Coal Co., 65 Minn. 442; 68 N. W. 70.

10 Anderson v. Bigelow, 16 Wash. 198; 47 Pac. 426.

17 Kinser v. Clay Co., 165 111. 505; 46 N. E. 372; affirming, 64 111. App. 437; Braun v. Hess, 187 111. 283; 58 N. E. 371; affirming 86 111. App. 544.

18 Sale of realty. Burks v. Hubbard, 69 Ala. 379; Dresden School Dist. v. Ins. Co., 62 Me. 330; Lumpkin v. Wilson, 5 Heisk. (Tenn.) 555.

19 McGrath v. Vanaman, 53 N. J. Eq. 459; 32 Atl. 686.

20 Diversy v. Kellogg, 44 111. 114; 92 Am. Dec. 154; West End, etc., Co. v. Crawford, 120 N. C. 347; 27 S. E. 31; Fletcher v. Nelson, 6 N. D. 94; 69 N. W. 53. Contra, Palmer v. Roath, 86 Mich. 602; 49 N. W. 590. But a state agent to sell machines has power to agree to take machine back if unsatisfactory. Marion Mfg. Co. Harding, 155 Ind. 648; 58 N. E. 194.

21 Chapman v. Hughes, 134 Cal. 641; 58 Pac. 298; 60 Pac. 974; 66 Pac. 982; Salem National Bank v. White, 159 111. 136; 42 N. E. 312; Minnesota Stoneware Co. v. Mc-Crossen, 110 Wis. 316; 84 Am. St. Rep. 927; 85 N. W. 1019.

22 Chapman v. Hughes, 134 Cal. 641; 58 Pac. 298; 60 Pac. 974; 66 Pac. 982.

23 Kiefer v. Klinsick, 144 Ind. 46; 42 N. E. 447.

24 Dreyfus v. Goss, 67 Kan. 57; 72 Pac. 537; McCormick Harvesting Machinery Co. v. Hiatt. - Neb. - ; 95 N. W. 627; Bierman v. Mills Co., 151 N. Y. 482; 56 Am. St. Rep. 635; 37 L. R. A. 799; 45 N. E. 856; Reese v. Bates, 94 Va. 321; 26 S. E. 865; Westurn v. Page, 94 Wis. 251; 68 N. W. 1003; Pickert v. Marston, 68 Wis. 465; 60 Am. Rep. 876; 32 N. W. '550; overruling Boothby v. Scales, 27 Wis. 626.

25 Reese v. Bates, 94 Va. 321; 26 S. E. 865; Westurn v. Page, 94 Wis. 251; 68 N. W. 1003; Larson v. Taylor Co., 86 Wis. 281; 39 Am. St. Rep. 893; 56 N. W. 915.

26 Hille v. Adair (Ky.), 58 S. W. 697; Reese v. Bates, 94 Va. 321; 26 S. E. 865.

27 Hille v. Adair (Ky.), 58 S. W. 697.

28 J. I. Case, etc., Co. v. McKin-non, 82 Minn. 75; 84 N. W. 646.

29 National Citizens' Bank v. Ertz, 83 Minn. 12; 53 L. R. A. 174; 85 N. W. 821.

30 Wait v. Bourne, 123 N. Y. 592; 25 N. E. 1053; Smith v. Tracy, 36 N. Y. 79.

31 Vanada v. Hopkins, 1 J. J. Mar. (Ky.) 285; 19 Am. Dec. 92; Bron-son v. Coffin, 118 Mass. 156; Le Roy v. Beard, 8 How. (U. S.) 451; Backman v Charlestown, 42 N. H. 125; Schultz v. Griffin, 121 N. Y. 294; 18 Am. St. Rep. 825; 24 N. E. 480; Peters v. Farnsworth. 15 Vt. 155; 40 Am. Dec. 671. Contra, see Howe v. Harrington, 18 N. J. Eq. 495.

32 Nelson v. Cowing, 6 Hill (N. Y.) 336; overruling Gibson v. Colt, 7 Johns. (N. Y.) 390; Nixon v. Hyseratt. 5 Johns. (N. Y.) 58.

33 Smith v. Mfg. Co., 58 N. J. L. 242; 33 Atl. 244.

34 Reeves v. Cress, 80 Minn. 466; 83 N. W. 443.

35 Taylor v. Bailey, 169 111. 181; 48 N. E. 200; affirming 68 111. App. 622.

36 Security Savings Bank v. Smith, 38 Or. 72; 84 Am. St. Rep. 756; 62 Pac 794.

37 Hayes' Appeal, 195 Pa. St. 177; 45 Atl. 1007.

38 In re Hale (1899), 2 Ch. 107. 39 Fortune v. Stockton. 182 111.

454: 55 X. E. 367; affirming 82 111. App. 272.

40 Bacon v. Pomeroy, 118 Mich. 145; 76 N. W. 324; Church Association v. Walton, 114 Mich. 677; 72 N. W. 998; Bromley v. Lathrop, 105 Mich. 492; 63 N. W. 510; Smith v. Kidd, 68 N. Y. 130; 23 Am. Rep. 157; Hollinshead v. Stuart, 8 N. D. 35; 42 L. R. A. 659; 77 N. W. 89; Bartel v. Brown, 104 Wis. 493; 80 N. W. 801; Kohl v. Beach, 107 Wis. 409; 81 Am. St. Rep. 849; 50 L. R. A. 600; 83 N. W. 657.

41 Harrison National Bank v. Austin, 65 Neb. 632; 91 N. W. 540.

42 Fradley v. Hyland, 37 Fed. 49; 2 L. R. A. 749; Wheeler v. McGuire, 86 Ala. 398; 2 L. R. A. 808; 5 So. 190; Chapman v. Oil Co., 117 Ga. 881; 45 S. E. 268.

43 Rogers v. College, 64 Ark. 627; 39 L. R. A. 636; 44 S. W. 454.

44 Van Vechten v. Jones, 104 Ia. 436; 73 N. W. 1032.

45Johnson v. Wilson, 137 Ala. 468; 97 Am. St. Rep. 52; 34 So. 392.

46 Hill v. Van Duzer, 111 Ga. 867; 36 S. E. 966. An agent to collect cannot set off his own debt to the debtor of the principal in payment of his principal's debt, leaving himself indebted to his principal. Western, etc.. Co. v. Portrey, 50 Nob. 801; 70 N. W. 383. (It is not a good novation, as the principal's consent is lacking. See Sec. 1351.

47 Deering v. Kelso, 74 Minn. 41; 73 Am. St. Rep. 324; 76 N. W. 792; Jackson v. Bank. 92 Tenn. 154; 36 Am. St. Rep. 81: 18 L. R. A. 663; 20 S. W. 802. Contra, if the agent collecting security of a loan association is to pay the money received therefrom to the treasurer he has authority to indorse. Gate City, etc., Association v. Bank, 126 Mo. 82; 47 Am. St. Rep. 633; 27 L. R. A. 401; 28 S. W. 633.

48 Karcher v. Gans, 13 S. D. 383; 83 N. W. 431.

49 Joy v. Vance, 104 Mich. 97; 62 N. W. 140; Walsh v. Peterson, 59 Neb. 645; 81 N. W. 853; Frey v. Curtis, 52 Neb. 406; 72 N. W. 478; Lawson v. Nicholson, 52 N. J. Eq. 821; 31 Atl. 386; Brewster v. Carnes, 103 N. Y. 556; 9 N. E. 323.

50 Little Rock, etc., Co. v. Wig gins, 65 Ark. 385; 46 S. W. 731; Dilenbeck v. Rehse, 105 Ia. 749; 73 N. W. 1072; Smith v. Kidd, 68 N. Y. 130; 23 Am. Rep. 157. •

51 Thornton v. Lawther, 169 111. 228; 48 N. E. 412; reversing 67 111. App. 214.

52 Springfield Savings Bank v. Kjaer, 82 Minn. 180; 84 N. W. 752.

53 Ambrose v. Barrett, 121 Cal. 297; 53 Pac. 805; 54 Pac. 264; Hitchcock v. Kelley, 18 Ohio C. C. 808; 4 Ohio C. D. 180.

54 Park v. Cross, 76 Minn. 187; 77 Am. St. Rep. 630; 78 N. W. 1107; Smith v. Kidd, 68 N. Y. 130; 23 Am. Rep. 157

55 Thornton v. Lawther, 169 111. 228; 48 N. E, 412; reversing 67 111. App. 214.

56 Dixon v. Guay, 70 N. H. 161; 46 Atl. 456. To the same effect is Cram v. Sickel, 51 Neb. 828; 66 Am. St. Rep. 478; 71 N. W. 724.

57 Nichols & Shepard Co. v. Hackney, 78 Minn. 461: 81 N. W. 322.

58 Oliver v. Sterling, 20 O. S. 391.

59 Strong v. West, 110 Ga. 382; 35 S. E. 693.

60 Jackson Paper Mfg. Co. v. Bank, 199 111. 151; 59 L. R. A. 657; 65 N. E. 136; Dreyfus v. Goss, 67 Kan. 57; 72 Pac. 537; Clark v. Murphy, 164 Mass. 490; 41 N. E.

674; Brown v. Lally, 79 Minn. 38; 81 N. W. 538; Smith v. Browne, 132 N. C. 365; 43 S. E. 915; Simon v. Johnson, 105 Ala. 344; 53 Am. St. Rep. 125; 16 So. 884.

61 Bingham v. Hibbard, 28 Or. 386; 43 Pac. 383.

62 John Matthews, etc., Co. v. Renz (Ky.), 61 S. W. 9.

63 California, etc., Works v. R. R. Co., 113 Cal. 329; 36 L. R. A. 648; 45 Pac. 691. But a vendor delivering live stock to the railroad is not the agent of the purchaser. Norfolk, etc., R. R. Co. v. Harman, 91 Va. 601; 50 Am. St. Rep. 855; 22 S. E. 490.

64 Ins. Co. v. Thornton, 130 Ala. 222; 55 L. R. A. 547; 30 So. 614.

65 Mutual Life Ins. Co. v. Logan, 87 Fed. 637; 31 C. C. A. 172.

66 Durkee v. Carr, 38 Or. 189; 63 Pac. 117.

67 Matteson v. Rice, 116 Wis. 328; 92 N. W. 1109.