Theory That Gratuitous Waiver Of Breach As Discharge Is Waiver Of Damages. Continued
Description
This section is from the book "The Law Of Contracts", by William Herbert Page. Also available from Amazon: Commercial Contracts: A Practical Guide to Deals, Contracts, Agreements and Promises.
Theory That Gratuitous Waiver Of Breach As Discharge Is Waiver Of Damages. Continued
4 Smith v. Wall, 12 Colo. 363, 21 Pac. 42; United Iron Works ▼. Rathskeller Co., 94 Wash. 67, L. R. A. 1017C, 445, 161 Pac. 1197.
5 Smith v. Wall, 12 Colo. 363, 21 Pac. 42.
1 England. Chanter v. Hopkins, 4 M. & W. 309.
United States. Marmot Coal Co. v. People's Coal Co., 226 Fed. 646.
Georgia. Miller v. Moore, 83 Ga. 684, 20 Am. St. Rep. 320, 6 L. R. A. 374, 10 S. E. 360.
Illinois. American Theatre Co. v. Siegel, 221 IlI 145, 4 L. R. A. '(N.S.) 1167, 77 N. E. 588.
Iowa. Keniston v. Todd, 139 la. 287, 117 N. W. 674.
Kentucky. Jones v. McEwan, 91 Ky. 373, 12 L. R. A. 390, 16 S. W 81.
Maryland. Eckels & Sons Ice Mfg. Co. v. Cornell Economizer Co., 119 Md 107, 86 Atl 38.
Nebraska. Patrick v. Norfolk Lumber Co., 81 Neb. 267, 116 N. W. 780
New Mexico. Cadwell v. Higgin-botham, 20 N. M. 482, 151 Pac 315.
New York. Reed v. Randall, 29 N. Y. 358, 86 Am. Dec 305; Pierson v. Crooks, 115 N. Y. 539, 12 Am. St. Rep. KM, 22 N. E. 349; Waeber v. Talbot, 1C7 N. Y. 48, 82 Am. St. Rep. 712, 60 N. E. 288.
Ohio. Bowman Lumber Co. v. Anderson, 70 O. S. 16, 70 N. E. 503.
South Dakota. Schmidt v. Jutting, 31 S. D. 69, 139 N. W. 769.
Washington. Maltbie v. Gadd, 101 Wash. 483, 172 Pac. 557.
Wisconsin. Northfield National Bank v. Arndt, 132 Wis. 383, 12 L. R. A. (N. S.) 82. 112 N. W. 451.
2 See Sec. 595 and 643.
3 England. Chanter v. Hopkins, 4 M. & W. 399.
Illinois. American Theatre Co. v. Siegel, 221 111. 145, 4 L. R. A. (N.S.) 1167, 77 N. E. 588.
Kentucky. Jones v. McEwan, 91 Ky. 373, 12 L. R. A. 399, 16 S. W. 81.
New York. Pierson v. Crooks, 115
N. Y. 539, 12 Am. St. Rep. 831, 22 N. E. 349.
Ohio. Bowman Lumber Co. v. Anderson, 70 O S. 16, 70 N. E. 503.
4 Georgia. Miller v. Moore, 83 Ga. 684, 20 Am. St. Rep. 329, 6 L. R. A. 374, 10 S. E. 360.
Iowa. Keniston v. Todd, 139 la. 287, 117 N. W. 674.
Kentucky. Jones v. McEwan, 91 Ky. 373, 12 L. R. A. 399, 16 S. W. 81.
Nebraska. Patrick v. Norfolk Lumber Co., 81 Neb. 267, 115 N. W. 780.
New York. Reed v. Randall, 29 N. Y. 358, 86 Am. Dec. 305; Waeber v. Talbot, 167 N. Y. 48, 82 Am. St. Rep. 712, 60 N. E. 288.
Wisconsin. Northfield National Bank v. Arndt, 132 Wis. 383, 12 L. R. A. (N.S.) 82, 112 N. W. 451.
5 United States. Marmet Coal Co. v. People's Coal Co., 226 Fed. 646.
Maryland. Eckels & Sons Ice Mfg. Co. v. Cornell Economizer Co., 119 Md. 107, 86 Atl. 38.
New Mexico. Cadwell v. Higgin-botham, 20 N. M. 482, 151 Pac. 315.
South Dakota. Schmidt v. Jutting, 31 S. D. 69, 139 N. W. 769.
Washington. Maltbie v. Gadd, 101 Wash. 483, 172 Pac 657.
with knowledge of a delay in delivering the goods, is held to be a * waiver of damages arising from such delay.11 It is sought to justify this result on the theory that there is no independent collateral warranty in these cases, but the so-called warranty is a condition of the contract, rather than a covenant; and that accordingly the acceptance of the articles which are offered, in the absence of fraud, operates as a complete discharge of obligation of the seller.12 If the agreement in contracts of this sort required
6 Maltbie v. Gadd, 101 Wash 483, 172 Pac 557.
7 United Iron Works v. Rathskeller Co., 94 Wash. 67, L. R. A. 1917C, 445, 161 Pac. 1197.
8 England. Chanter v. Hopkins, 4 M. & W. 399.
Florida. American Mfg. Co. v. Mc-Leod, - Fla. -, 82 So. 802 (obiter).
Illinois. American Theatre Co. v. Siegel, 221 111. 145, 4 L. R. A. (NS) 1167, 77 N. E. 588.
Kentucky. Jones v. McEwan, 91 Ky. 373, 12 L. R. A. 399, 16 8. W. 81.
Hew York. Pierson v. Crooks, 115 N. Y. 539, 12 Am. St. Rep. 831, 22 N. E. 349.
Ohio. Bowman Lumber Co. v. Anderson, 70 O. S. 16, 70 N. E. 503.
Oklahoma. Marks v. Stein, - Okla. -, 160 Pac. 318.
9 England. Chanter v. Hopkins, 4 M. & W. 399.
Illinois. American Theatre Co. v. Siegel, 221 III. 145, 4 L. R. A. (N.S ) 1167, 77 N. E. 588.
Kentucky. Jones v. McEwan, 91 Ky. 373, 12 L. R A. 399, 10 S. W. 81.
New York. Pierson v. Crooks, 115 N. Y. 539, 12 Am. St. Rep. 831, 22 N. E. 349.
Ohio. Bowman Lumber Co. v. Anderson, 70 O. S. 16, 70 N. E. 503.
10 Remy v. Healy, 161 Mich. 266, 29 L. R. A. (N.S.) 139, 126 N. W. 202 (obiter); Marks v. Stein, - Okla. -, 160 Pac. 318.
11 Medart Pulley Co. v. Dubuque Turbine & Roller Mill Co., 121 la. 244, 96 N. W. 770.
12Hurley-Mason Co. v. Stebbins, 79 Wash 366, L. R. A. 1915B, 1131, 140 Pac. 381.
13 Pieraon v. Crooks, 115 N. Y. 639, 12 Am. St. Rep. 831, 22 N. E. 340 [quoted in Bowman Lumber Co. v. Anderson, 70 O. S. 16, 70 N. E. 503].
14 American Mfg. Co. v. McLeod, -Fla. -, 82 So. 802.
15Victor Chemical Works v. Hill Clutch Co., 152 Fed. 303, 10 L. R. A. (N.S.) 814.
16 Dean v. Connecticut Tobacco Corporation, 88 Conn. 619, 92 Atl. 408.
17 Delaware, Lackawanna & Western R. R. Co. v. Monroe County Water Power & Supply Co., 221 Pa. St. 387, 70 Atl. 797.
18 Delaware, Lackawanna & Western Ry. Co. v. Monroe County Water Power & Supply Co., 221 Pa. St. 387, 70 Atl. 797.
19 Louisville & Nashville Ry. v. Mason & Hoge Co. (Ky.), 104 S. W. 975.
20 Louisville & Nashville Ry. v. Mason & Hoge Co. (Ky.), 104 S. W. 975.
21 Brighton v. Lake Shore & Michigan Southern Ry., 103 Mich. 420, 61 N. W. 660.
22 Brighton v. Lake Shore & Michigan Southern Ry., 103 Mich. 420, 61 N. W. 550.
23Creston Water Works v. Creston, 101 la. 687, 70 N. W. 739.
Continue to:
My Books
