This section is from the book "American Law Of Real Estate Agency", by William Slee Walker. Also available from Amazon: American law of real estate agency.
A broker interfering with another's transaction is not entitled to a commission. Reynolds v. Tompkins, 23 W. Va. 229; Jenks v. Nobles, 42 I11. App. 33. Where a broker to sell advertises the property and shows it to a person, and another broker buys the property and conveys it to that person, the first broker is entitled to recover commissions. Elemendorf v. Golden, 37 Wash. 664, 80 P. 264.
Where a broker, through a letter improperly reaching him, obtains information and directs the seeker to the owner, he is not entitled to commissions on an exchange of properties afterwards effected. Hamilton v. Gillander, 49 N. Y. S. 663, 26 App. Div. 156. Where a broker, through a mistake in telephoning the owner, telephoned another broker bearing the same name, who thereupon effected a sale, the latter was not entitled to commissions. Shapiro v. Shapiro, 103 N. Y. S. 305, 117 App. Div. 817. Where a broker was negotiating with a customer whom he introduced to the owner, and the latter told the customer he could buy cheaper through another agency, and a sale was effected through the latter, the former agent was entitled to the commission. Gilmore v. Freshaur, 126 Mo. App. 299, 102 S. W. 1107.
A broker who fails to procure a purchaser on the terms proposed and another interferes and sells on different terms, or at the same price, is not entitled to commissions. Carlson v. Nathan, 43 I11. App. 364; Armes v. Cameron, 19 D. C. 435; Mears v. Stone, 44 I11. App. 444; Tinsley v. Scott, 69 I11. App. 352; Livezy v. Miller, 61 Md. 336; Crowning shield v. Foster, 169 Mass. 237, 47 N. E. 879; Wolff v. Rosenberg, 67 Mo. App. 403; Northcupp v. Biggs, 128 Mo. App. 217, 106 S. W. 1123; Chandler v. Sutton, 5 Daly (N. Y.), 112; Powell v. Anderson, 15 Daly, 219, 4 N. Y. S. 706; Holly v. Townsend, 2 Hilt. (N. Y.) 34; De Zavola v. Rozaliner, 84 N. Y. S. 969; Friedman v. Havemeyer, 56 N. Y. S. 97, 37 App. Div. 518;
Felman v. O'Brien, 51 N. Y. S. 309, 23 Misc. 341; Powell v. Lamb, 1 N. Y. S. 431; Rae v. Kane, 106 N. Y. S. 47, 121 App. Div. 494; Land Mtge. Bk. v. Hargis (Texas Civ. App. '02), 70 S. W. 352.
Where a broker put his principal into communication with a prospective purchaser, who proposed making a proposition, but later bought the property through another agent at a slightly reduced price, the first agent having set on foot inquiries and negotiations that culminated in a sale, was entitled to the commissions. Cunliff v. Hansmann, 97 Mo. App. 467, 71 S. W. 368; Shinn v. Evans, 37 App. D. C. 304. Compare Sec. 290.
A broker is entitled to commissions where the principal interferes with the customer and concludes the transaction himself. Williams v. Bishop, 11 Colo. App. 378, 53 P. 239.
A broker who finds a purchaser and negotiates with him to sell the land, and when the sale is nearly completed, another broker meets the customer, who tells him of the offer made by the first broker, and with full knowledge of the first broker's negotiations the second broker sells the property for a less sum to the customer, and the owner, ignorant of the first broker's negotiations, concludes the transaction, the owner is liable for commissions to the first broker. Reynolds v. Tompkins, 23 W. Va. 229; Lewis v. McDonald, 83 Neb. 694, 120 N. W. 207. See also Sec. 446.
The principal can not interfere with negotiations started by the broker, revoke his authority, and sell the land to his customer, or through another broker, and escape liability for commissions to the first broker, the customer not having abandoned the idea of purchasing. Day v. Porter, 161 I11. 235, 43 N. E. 1073; Gillet v. Corum, 7 Kan. 156; Corning v. Calvert, 2 Hilt. (N. Y.) 56; Budd v. Zoiler, 52 Mo. 238; Newton v. Conness (Tex. Civ. App. '08), 106 S. W. 892.
 
Continue to: