The "burden of proof" is the legal duty resting upon a party litigant, at some stage in the trial of a civil case, to introduce evidence of preponderating weight on an issue which he asserts, to overcome the proof offered on that issue by his opponent.

In a criminal case, the presumption is that every man is innocent until his guilt is proved beyond a reasonable doubt, and the burden is on the State to prove every fact and circumstance essential to the guilt of the accused, and each and every element of the offense charged, beyond a reasonable doubt.1

By some authorities, it is claimed that the burden of proof never shifts; by others it is claimed that it continually shifts. The difficulty seems to lie in the fact that the term is used in two different senses; (1) The duty of introducing a preponderance of evidence; and (2) the duty of meeting and overcoming a prima facie case.2 According to the decided weight of current decisions, the former remains fixed and inflexible. The latter may shift back and forth with the ebb and flow of the testimony.

In a civil case, when it is necessary to prove the commission of a crime, in some jurisdictions it has been held that such crime must be proved beyond a reasonable doubt;3 and this is especially true where the crime is charged in the pleadings.4

1 State vs. Hardelein, 169 Mo., 579; 70 S. W., 130; Huggins vs. State, 42 Tex. Crim., 364, 60 S. W., 52; U. S. vs. Gooding, 12 Wheat., 460; People vs. Downs, 123 N. Y., 558, 25 N.

E., 988; State vs. Bartlett, 43 N. H., 224; Alexander vs. People, 96 I11., 96. 2 Scott vs. Wood, 81 Cal., 398, 32 Pac, 871.

Where the evidence is largely circumstantial, some authorities have held that each link in the chain of circumstantial evidence must be proved beyond a reasonable doubt, and that if the jury entertain doubt as to any of the facts they may acquit.5