A great difference of opinion exists as to the comparative merits of the Labrador and the curly-coated retriever for water. In any case, the latter is not improved by the setter cross for this purpose, as the coat of that dog is not nearly so oily as the Labrador's. As far as I can learn from wildfowlers, there is no reliable evidence to found an opinion on.

In tenderness of mouth the wavy-coated dog is said to be superior to his rival, but without doubt there are many curly-coated retrievers whose mouths are tender enough. Notably Mr. Gorse's Jet was so; and, indeed, from "information received," . I am led to believe that he was far above the average in this respect as well as in nose. The Irish water spaniel makes an excellent water retriever, as does the poodle also.