This section is from the book "Safe Building", by Louis De Coppet Berg. Also available from Amazon: Code Check: An Illustrated Guide to Building a Safe House.
We will calculate the thickness required at first story beam level, Figure 88.
The load is, per running foot of wall:
Wall of Country House.
Slate roof (incl wind and snow)
For the quality of brick described we should take from Table V:
(c/f) = 200 lbs.
The height between floors is 10 feet, or L=10, therefore, using formula (62) we have: w = d.(c/f)/0,0833+0,0475. l2/d2 = 12.200/0,0833+0,475. 10.10/12.12 = 5807 lbs.
bo that the wall is amply strong. If the wall were pierced to the extent of one-quarter with openings, the weight per running foot would be increased to 6525 lbs. Over 700 lbs. more than the safe load, still the wall, even then, would be safe enough, as Ave have allowed some 330 lbs. for wind, which would rarely, if ever, be so strong; and further, some 1200 lbs. for loads on floors, also a very ample allowance; and even if the two ever did exist together it would only run the compression (c/f) up to 225 lbs. per inch, and for a temporary stress this can be safely allowed.
The writer would state here, that the only fault he finds with formulae (59), (60), (62) and (63), is that their results are apt to give an excess of strength; still it is better to be in fault on the safe side and be sure.
The brick walls of a warehouse are 115 feet high, the 8 stories are each 14 feet high from floor to floor, or 12 feet in the clear. The load on floors per square foot, including the fire-proof construction, will average 300 lbs. What size should the walls be? The span of beams is 26 feet on an average. (See Fig. 89, page 142.)
According to the New York Building Law, the required thicknesses would be: first story, 32"; second, third, and fourth stories, 28"; fifth and sixth stories, 24"; seventh and eighth stories, 20".
At the seventh story level we have a load, as follows, for each running foot of wall:
Walls of City Warehouse.
11960 lbs., or 6 tons.
The safe load on a 20" wall 12 feet high, from formula (63) is: w = 1 2/3.200/14+0,552. 12.12/1 2/3.1 2/3 = 333/14+0,552.51,84 = 7,84 tons, or
If one-quarter of the wall were used up for openings, slots, flues, etc., the load on the balance would be 8 tons per running foot, which is still safe, according to our formula.
At the fifth-story level the load would be:
Load above seventh floor
Sixth and seventh floors
26872 lbs. or 13 1/2
The safe load on a 24" wall, 12 feet high, from formula (G3) is:
W = 2.200/14+0,552. 12.12/2.2 = 400/14+0,552.36 = 11,809 tons, or 23618 lbs.
This is about 10 per cent less than the load, and can be passed as safe, but if there were many flues, openings, etc., in wall, it should be thickened.
At the second-story level the load would be:
Load above fifth floor
42. 2 1/3.112
Third, fourth and fifth floors
Total 25 tons.
The safe-load on a 28" wall, 12 feet high, from formula (63) is:
W = 2 1/3.200/14+0,552. 12.12/2 1/3. 2 1/. = 467/14+0,552.26.45 = 16,33 tons, or 32660 lbs.
Or, the wall would be dangerously weak at the second-floor level.
At the first-floor level the load would be:
Load above second floor
14. 2 2/3.112
59309, or 29 1/2 tons
The safe-load on a 32" wall, 12 feet high, from formula (63) is:
W = 2 2/3.200/14+0,552. 12.12/2 2/3. 2 2/3 = 533/14+0,552.2025 = 21,169 tons,
or 42338 lbs.
The wall would, therefore, be weak at this point, too.
Now while the conditions we have assumed, an eight-story warehouse with all floors heavily loaded, would be very unusual, it answers to show how impossible it is to cover every case by a law, not based on the conditions of load, etc. In reality the arrangements of walls, as required by the law, are foolish. Unnecessary weight is piled on top of the wall by making the top 20" thick, which wall has nothing to do but to carry the roof. (If the span of beams were increased to 31 feet or more the law compels this top wall to be 24" thick, if 41 feet, it would have to be 28" thick, an evident waste of material.) It would be much better to make the top walls lighter, and add to the bottom; in this case, the writer would suggest that the eighth story be 12"; the seventh story 16"; the sixth story, 20"; the fifth story, 24"; the fourth story, 28"; the third story, 32"; the second story, 36", and the first story 40", see Figure 90. (Page 142.)
This would represent but 4 2/3 cubic feet of additional brickwork for every running foot of wall; or, if we make the first-story wall 36" too, as hereafter suggested, the amount of material would be exactly the same as required by the law, and yet the wall would be much better proportioned and stronger as a whole. For we should find (for L = 12 feet),
Actual load at eighth-floor level,
Safe load on a 12" wall from Formula (62)
Actual load at seventh-floor level,
Safe load on a 16" wall from Formula (62)
Actual load at sixth-floor level,
Safe load on a 20" wall from Formula (62)
Actual load at fifth-floor level,
Safe load on a 24" wall from Formula (62)
Actual load at fourth-floor level,
Safe load on a 28" wall from Formula (62)
Actual load at third-floor level,
Safe load on a 32" wall from Formula (62)
Actual load at second-floor level,
Safe load on a 36" wall from Formula (62)
Actual load at first-floor level,
Safe load on a 40" wall from Formula (62)
The first-story wall could safely be made 36" if the brickwork is good, and there are not many flues, etc., in walls, for then we could use
(c/f) = 250, which would give a safe load on a 36" wall = 65127 lbs., or more than enough.
The above table shows how very closely the Formula (62) would agree with a practical and common-sense arrangement of exactly the same amount of material, as required by the law.
Now, if the upper floor were laden with barrels, there might be some danger of these thrusting out the wall. We will suppose an extreme case, four layers of flour barrels packed against the wall, leaving a 5-foot aisle in the centre. We should have 20 barrels in each row ( Fig. 91), weighing in all 20.19C = 3920 lbs. These could not well be placed closer than 3 feet from end to end, or, say, 1307 lbs., per running foot of wall; of this amount only one-half will thrust against wall, or, say, 650 pounds. The radius of the barrel is about 20". If Figure 92 represents three of the barrels, and we make A B = to, = 1/2 the load of the flour barrels, per running foot of walls, it is evident that D B will represent the horizontal thrust on wall, per running foot. As D B is the radius, and as we know that A D = 2 D B or = 2 radii, we can easily find A B, for: