17 Rector v. Deposit Co., 100 111. 380, 60 N. E. 528.

18Gilbert v. Stockman, 76 Wis. 62. 20 Am. St. Rep. 23, 44 N. W. 845, and see Garwood v. Wheaton, 128 Cal. 399, 60 Pac. 961.

19 Stanisics v. McMurtry, 64 Neb. 761, 90 N. W. 884.

20Meader v. Allen, 110 Ia. 588, 81 N. W. 799.

21 Stowell v. Ins. Co., 163 N. Y. 298, 57 N. E. 480.

22 Hopkins v. Ry., 29 Kan. 544

1 United States. Smith v. Bank, 89 Fed. 832, 32 C. C. A. 368; Housekeeper Publishing Co. v. Swift, 97 Fed. 290. 38 C. C. A. 187: El Dia Insurance Co. v. Sinclair, 228 Fed. 833, 143 C. C. A. 231; President Suspender Co. v. Macwilliam, 238 Fed. 159, 151 C. C. A. 235 [affirming. President Suspender Co. v Macwilliam, 233 Fed. 433]; Stark Electric R. Co. v. McGinty Contracting Co., 238 Fed. 657, 151 C. C. A. 507; Hazen Mfg. Co. v. Wareham, 242 Fed. 642.

Alabama. Bomar v. Rosser, 131 Ala. 215, 31 So. 430; Manchester Sawmills Co. v. A. L. Arundel Co., 197 Ala. 505, 73 So. 24.

Arizona. Hurley v. Young Men's Christian Association, 16 Ariz. 26, 52 L. R. A. (N.S.) 221, 140 Pac. 816.

Arkansas. Fears v. Watson, 124 Ark. 341, 187 S. W. 178; Luce v. Arkansas Brick & Mfg. Co., 125 Ark. 219, 188 S. W. 566.

California. In re Gurnsey's Estate, - Cal. - . 170 Pac. 402; Budd v. Hughes, - Cal. - , 171 Pac. 287.

Colorado. Brown v. Barth, - Colo. - , 184 Pac. 300.

Connecticut. Adams v. Turner, 73 Conn. 38, 46 Atl. 247.

District of Columbia. Gerber v. Probey, 44 D. C. App. 392.

Georgia. Maxwell v. Willingham, 101 Ga. 55, 28 S. E. 672; Carter v Williamson, 106 Ga. 280, 31 S. E. 651; American Harrow Company v. Dolvin, 119 Ga. 186, 45 S. E. 083; Townsend v. Southern Product Co., 127 Ga. 342, 119 Am. St. Rep. 340, 56 S. E. 436.

Illinois. Diederick v. Rose, 228 111. 610, 81 N. E. 1140.

Iowa. Becker v. Dalby (Ia.), 86 N. W. 314.

Kansas. Graham County Mill & Elevator Co. v. Saunders, 96 Kan. 459, 152 Pac. 622; German-American State Bank v. Watson, 99 Kan. 686, 163 Pac. 637; First National Bank v. Staab, 102 Kan. 360, 171 Pac. 3; Fontron v. Kruse, - Kan. - , 172 Pac. 1007.

Kentucky. White v. Williams, 105 Ky. 802, 40 S. W. 808; Crane v. Williamson, 111 Ky. 271, 63 S. W. 610, 975.

Louisiana. St. Landry State Bank v. Meyers, 52 La. Ann. 1769, 28 So. 136.

Michigan. Wallace v. Kelly, 148 Mich. 336, 118 Am. St. Rep. 580, 111 N. W. 1049.

Minnesota. Baylor v. Butterfass, 32 Minn. 21, 84 N. W. 640; Northwestern Fuel Co. v. Boston Insurance Co., 131 Minn. 19, 154 N. W. 515.

Mississippi. Cooper v. Robertson Investment Co., 117 Miss. 108, 77 So. 953.

Montana. Ming v. Pratt, 22 Mont. 262, 56 Pac. 279.

Nebraska. Aultman v. Hawk (Neb.), 95 N. W. 695.

New Jersey. Kupferschmidt v. Agricultural Insurance Co., 80 N. J. L. 441, 34 L. R. A. (N.S.) 503, 78 Atl. 225: Ferber v. Cona, - N. J. - , 103 Atl. 471.

New Mexico. Locke v. Murdoch, 20 N. M. 522, L. R. A. 1917B, 267, 151 Pac. 298; Gooch v. Coleman, 22 N. M. 45, 159 Pac. 945.

North Carolina. Hoffman v. Accident Co., 127 N. Car. 337, 37 S. E. 466; Kernodle v. Williams, 153 N. Car. 475, 34 L.'R. A. (N.S.) 934, 69 S. E. 431; Acme Manufacturing Co. v. McCormick, 175 N. Car. 277, L. R. A. 1918F, 572. 95 S. E. 555.

North Dakota. Gile v. Interstate Motor Car Co., 27 N. D. 108, L. R. A. 1915B, 109, 145 N. W. 732.

Ohio. Harley v. Weber, 1 Ohio C. D. 360; First National Bank v. Chandelier Co., 17 Ohio C. C. 443.

Oklahoma. Deming Investment Co. v. Shawnee F. Ins. Co., 16 Okla. 1, 4 L. R. A. (N.S.) 607, 83 Pac. 918; Gish v. Insurance Co., 16 Okla. 59, 13 L. R. A. (N.S.) 826, 87 Pac. 869; First National Bank v. Sappington, - Okla. - , 157 Pac. 937.

Oregon. Muir v. Morris, 80 Or. 378, 157 Pac. 785 [denying rehearing, Muir v. Morris, 80 Or. 378, 154 Pac. 117]; Leavitt v. Dimmick, 86 Or. 278, 168 Pac. 292.

Pennsylvania. Ivery v. Phillips, 196 Pa. St. 1, 46 Atl. 133; Kaufmann v. Friday, 201 Pa. St. 178, 50 Atl. 942.

South Carolina. Burwell & Dunn Co. v. Chapman, 59 S. Car. 581, 38 S. E. 222: Gill v. Ruggles, 104 S. Car. 461, 80 S. E. 503.

South Dakota. Black Hills Trust & Savings Bank v. Plunkett, - S. D. - 166 N. W. 527.

Utah. Rampton v. Cole, - Utah - . 172 Pac. 477.

Virginia. Connecticut Fire Ins. Co. v.W. H. Roberts Lumber Co., 119 Va. 479, 89 S. E. 945; Hoster's Committee v. Zollman, 122 Va. 41, 94 S. E. 164: Holt Mfg. Co. v. Brotherton, 91 Wash. 354, 157 Pac. 849.

West Virginia. Martin v. Ry., 48 W. Va. 642, 37 S. E. 563; Clarksburg Board of Trade Land Co. v. Davis, 77 w. Va. 70, 86 S. . 029; Mineral Ridge Mfg. Co. v. Smith, 79 W. Va. 736, 91 S. E. 817.

Wisconsin. Newell v. Canning Co., 119 Wis. 635, 97 N. W. 487; Coman v. Wunderlich, 122 Wis. 138, 99 N. W. 612; Neff v. Rubin, 161 Wis. 511, 154 N. W. 976.

2 Engles v. Blocker, 127 Ark. 385, 192 S. W. 193.

3 Cochran v.,Zachery, 137 Ia. 585, 16 L. R. A. (N.S.) 235, 115 N. W. 486; Fontron v. Kruse, - Kan. - , 172 Pac. 1007; Northern Assurance Co. v. Meyer, 194 Mich. 371, 160 N. W. 617; Acme Manufacturing Co. v. McCormick, 175 N. Car. 277, L. R. A. 1918F, 572, 95 S. E. 555.

4 Cochran v. Zachery, 137 Ia. 585, 16 L. R. A. (N.S.) 235, 115 N. W. 486;

Fontron v. Kruse, - Kan. - , 172 Pac. 1007.

5 Northern Assurance Co. v. Meyer, 194 Mich. 371. 160 N. W. 617.

6 Pierce v. Cobb, 161 N. Car. 300, 44 L. R. A. (N.S.) 370, 77 S. E. 350.

7Pritchett v. Jenkins, 52 Mont. 81, 155 Pac. 974; Schwartzman v. Crevel-ing, 85 N. J. Eq. 402, 96 Atl. 896.

8 Schwartzman v. Creveling, 85 N. J. Eq. 402, 96 Atl. 896.

9Hodson v. Varney, 122 Cal. 619, 56 Pac. 413.

10Drum-Flato Commission Co. v Barnard, 66 Kan. 568, 72 Pac. 257: Lawrence v. Com stock, 124 Mich. 120, 82 N. W. 808.

11 Finnigan v. Shaw, 184 Mass. 112, 68 N. E. 35.

12Fears v. Watson, 124 Ark. 341, 187 S. W. 178.

13Gerber v. Probey, 44 D. C. App. 392.

14 Slump v. Blain, 177 la. 239, 158 N. W. 491.