This section is from the book "Style In Furniture", by R. Davis Benn. Also available from Amazon: Style In Furniture.
Considerable attention was devoted to their design. The earlier caddies were often of soft wood, lacquered in black and gold, and not infrequently covered with the most elaborate diapers and "powdering"; but those with which we are now concerned were, as I have indicated, generally made either of mahogany, inlaid with satinwood or canary-wood and other coloured marquetry, or of satinwood itself, delicately painted or inlaid, after the manner indicated by the illustrations to which I have referred. In addition to serving faithfully a most important utilitarian purpose, they were, in themselves, oftentimes actually things of beauty; and, in conjunction with the knife-cases by which they were usually "supported" on either side, went far to enhance the general effect of the old sideboards whereon they were placed, and of which they seemed to constitute an essential feature. But they have gone, I suppose never to return, for has not a less expensive substitute for them been found? We now have the cheap, enamelled, tin receptacles, which, no one can deny, serve their purpose sufficiently well; but it is certain that they will never give pleasure to the eye. All, therefore, who are so fortunate as to possess caddies of the good old-fashioned sort should treasure them carefully. They are becoming more difficult to secure every day, and those who desire to include fine examples in their collections will do well to "snap at" any that may come their way - provided, of course, that they are worth having.
"Heppelwhite.'- II. Plate 44

Page | |||||
Figs. | 1-5 | See | 140 | ||
" | 6 | " | 138, | 140 | |
" | 7,8. | " | 140 | ||
" | 9 | " | 140, | 141. | 247 |
Page | ||||
Figs. | 10, | 11. | See | 140 |
" | 12. | " | 261 | |
" | 13. | 14. | " | 141 |
" | 15 | " | 138, 141 |
Page | ||||
Figs. | 16-18. | See | 141 | |
" | 19-24. | " | 142 | |
" | 25,27 | " | 142, | 261 |
" | 26, 28. | " | 142 | |
Before leaving the consideration of this Plate (III.), I may point out that the very fact of the appearance of so many pieces of what may be described as fancy furniture in a single design book of the period in question is sufficient evidence that the reign of elegance had seriously commenced, and that utility, though by no means forgotten, was no longer regarded as the only and all-important quality to be secured. The demands of the graces of life were increasing.
We will turn now to the consideration of more pretentious productions, technically known to the cabinet maker as "carcase work." Plate IV. is devoted to a variety of appointments for the library and study, apartments which, whether they were seriously used for their proper purposes or not, were made much of in those days when it was fashionable to ape a knowledge of literature, and when the slightest pretensions to its cultivation were often sufficient to insure an entree into the most exclusive social circles; provided, of course, that they were put forward with sufficient assurance. The penning of billets-doux, sonnets, and love-sick verses, of every length and metre, with fulsome adulation of "my lady's eyes," or wails of hopeless despair at her unrelenting coldness, were the order of the day; and the reputation of a man who aspired to write an epic poem on the one hand, or a play on the other, was assured, even though it may never have been destined to see the light. Simply to have your name on the list of subscribers for any projected magnum opus was to attain notoriety. Can we then be surprised if every home that boasted a room to spare devoted it presumably to the pursuit of literary studies?
So far as it lay within their power the cabinet makers, of course, were ready and willing to encourage and foster the existence of this state of things; for it suited them admirably. In order to do so, and help at the same time to fill their order books, they devised all manner of articles designed to enhance the convenience and comfort of reading and writing, and for the reception of books and the storage of papers. Many of these were the direct ancestors of some of the most indispensable furnishing adjuncts of the well-appointed library and study of to-day.
The articles represented in Figs,1i, 3, and 4, Plate IV., variously termed "secretary bookcases," "bureau bookcases," "escritoires," and "secretaires," represent a type the manufacture of which was extensively cultivated. Similar ones were, as we have seen, well known at a much earlier date, and their lasting popularity is not one-whit to be wondered at, for now, as then, they are a veritable "boon and blessing" to the literarily inclined, who desire to have their necessary books of reference and favourite authors handy, and their papers safe from the terrors of "tidying" operations, and the soul-stirring, as well as dust-stirring, ravages wrought by the ubiquitous duster.
Secretaires almost precisely similar in character to those under consideration are still manufactured in very large numbers, but they have found a remarkably strong rival in the modern American "roll-top" desk; an article which, during the past fifteen or twenty years, has been imported into this country by tens of thousands. Against this importation, regarded strictly from the utilitarian point of view, I have not a single word to say. The "roll-top" desk, indeed, provided it be by one of the reputable manufacturers, is in every respect an ideal one for the busy man who can dispense with art in commercial affairs; but, regarded from the purely artistic point of view, it is, to put it mildly, unattractive in every sense of the word. Though tolerated, nay, even heartily welcome in the office, where we do not usually expect to find beauty - though why we should not I am unable to say - its presence in any well-furnished library, study, or "den" jars very considerably upon the sensibilities, and makes us long sincerely for the substitution of some such "secretary bookcase" as those which these cabinet makers of the old times revelled in designing.
"Heppelwhite." III. Plate 45

Page | |||||||||
Figs. | 1, | 5, | 7, | 9, | 11, | See | 144 | ||
" | 2, | 3, | 4, | 6, | 8, | 10, | " | 143. | 246 |
Page | ||||||||
Figs. | 16, | 17, | 18, | 19, | 20, | See | 143, | 246 |
" | 12, | 13, | 14, | 15, | " | 145 | ||
Figure 5 is a bookcase, or " library-case" as they were styled in those days. Like nearly all other cabinet work of this period, these were made in mahogany, but a variation was occasionally introduced in the tracery of the doors. This was usually of the same wood as that of the main body, or "carcase," of the article, though occasionally, as in Fig. 5, it was carried out in metal - preferably brass - "which," says Heppelwhite, "painted of a light colour, or gilt, will produce a light, pleasing effect." In "library-cases" of this precise type, it appears, at a first glance, as though no accommodation for writing was to be looked for in the scheme; and any one might easily, and quite naturally, put them down as bookcases pure and simple. But on pulling out the centre drawer, or "secretary-drawer" as it was termed, ample writing surface, pigeon-holes, ink-wells, small drawers, and all manner of other conveniences were revealed; while beneath were shelves and larger drawers of more than average dimensions for portfolios, papers, books, etc.
Referring specially to the enrichment of glazed doors by the introduction of wood, or metal, tracery, a plan greatly favoured by our late eighteenth-century cabinet makers, Heppelwhite points out: "The patterns may be greatly varied." He illustrates the truth of this contention by presenting a large number of designs for them, a selection of the most typical of which is shown at the bottom of the plate at present under discussion. But how is the "Heppelwhite" tracery to be distinguished from others? We shall find that even a careful comparison of these with those that came from the pencil of Sheraton, many of which are illustrated in the fol-owing chapter, will leave the reader in a position of no small difficulty when he has to distinguish between the two styles; for the details in both are puzzlingly similar - indeed, not infrequently precisely the same.
 
Continue to: