2 Floete v. Brown. 104 Ia. 154; 65 Am. St. .Rep. 434; 73 N. W. 483.

3 Batesville Institute v. Kauffman, 18 Wall. (U. S.) 151; Hurt v. Wilson, 38 Cal. 263; Miller v. Larned, 103 I11. 562; Connecticut Ins. Co. v. Talbot. 113 Ind. 373; 3 Am. St. Rep. 655; 14 N. E. 586; Morris v. Bacon. 123 Mass. 58; 25 Am. Rep. 17.

4 Johnson v. Clarke (N. J. Eq.), 28 Atl. 558.

5 Van Pelt v. Hurt, 97 Ga. 660: 25 S. E. 489.

6 Chestnut Hill Reservoir Co. v Chase. 14 Conn. 123.

7 Lemmon v. Strong, 59 Conn. 448; 21 Am. St. Rep. 123; 12 L. R. A. 293; 22 Atl. 293; Anchor Investment Co. v. Kirkpatrick, 59 Minn. 378; 50 Am. St. Rep. 417; 61 N. W. 29; Sepp v. MeCann, 47 Minn. 364; 50 N. W. 246; Wool ley v. Moore. 61 N. J. L. 16; 38 Atl. 758; Hayden v. Weldon, 43 N. J. L. 128; 39 Am. Rep. 551; Stillman v. Northrup, 109 N.Y. 473; 17 N. E. 379; Claflin v. Ostrom, 54 X. Y. 581; Craig v. Par-kis, 40 N. Y. 181; 100 Am. Dec. 469; Tidioute Savings Bank v. Lib-bey, 101 Wis. 193; 70 Am. St. Rep. 907; 77 N. W. 182.

8 An indorsement. "We hereby guarantee the payment within note," properly signed, was held personal. Edgerly v. Lawson, 170 Mass. 551; 51 L. R. A. 432; 57 N. E. 1020.

9 Schoonover v. Osborne, 108 la. 453; 79 N. W. 263.

10 Southern Paving Co. v. Chattanooga (Tenn. Ch. App.), 48 S. W. 92. (Assignee of benefits of a street paving contract may make repairs during the five year period and collect the fund reserved to enforce such repairs, the assignor having given bond to the assignee to make required repairs.)

11 Day v. Vinson, 78 Wis. 198; 10 L. P. A. 205; 47 N. W. 269.

12 Snyder v. Critchfield, 44 Neb. 66; 62 N. W. 306 (under Pennsylvania law).

13 Nix v. Ellis, 118 Ga. 345; 98 Am. St. Rep. Ill; 45 S. E. 404; Jack v. Klepson, 196 Pa. St. 187; 79 Am. St. Rep. 699; 46 Atl. 479.

14 Defense of limitations. Walker v. Burgess, 44 W. Va. 399; 67 Am. St. Rep. 775: 30 S. E. 99. Defense that debt was for personal services (painting a picture) and by statute not subject to set-off. Mil-lington v. Laurer, 89 Ia. 322: 48 Am. St. Rep. 385; 56 N. W. 533.

15 Metropolitan Life Ins. Co. v. Fuller. 61 Conn. 252; 29 Am. St. Rep. 196; 23 Atl. 193; National Valley Bank v. Hancock. 100 Va. 101: 40 S. E. 611.

16 Howd v. Breckenridse. 97 Mich. 65; 56 X. W. 221: Billingsley v. Clelland. 41 W. Va. 234; 23 S. E. 812.

17Hicks v. Steel, 126 Mich. 408; 85 N. W. 1121.

18 Abrahamson v. Lamberson, 72 Minn. 308; 75 N. W. 226 (where recovery was had against a vendor of realty for wrongful taking of possession and removal of buildings).

19 Munson v. Bank, 19 Wash. 125; 52 Pac. 1011 (negligence of a collecting bank to notify indorsers of non-payment).

20 Citizen's National Bank v. Loomis, 100 Ia. 266; 62 Am. St. Eep. 571; 69 N. W. 443 (negligence of officer in levying attachment).

21 Malloy v. Malloy, 35 Neb. 224; 52 N. W. 1097.

22 Douglass v. Blount, 95 Tex.

369; 58 L. R. A. 699; 67 S. W. 484.

23 Ross-Meehan Foundry Co. v. Ice Co., 72 Miss. 608; 18 So. 364; Landigan v. Mayer, 32 Or. 245; 67 Am. St. Rep. 521; 51 Pac. 649.

24 Dolliff v. Robbins, 83 Minn. 498; 85 Am. St. Rep. 466; 86 N. W. 772.

25 Caulfield v. Van Brunt, 173 Pa. St. 428; 34 Atl. 230.

26 Garretson v. Ferrall, 78 la. 166; 6 L. R. A. 377; 42 N. W. 637.

27 Bennett v. Lathrop, 71 Conn. 613; 71 Am. St. Rep. 222; 42 Atl. 634.

28 De Graffenreid v. Ry., 66 Ark. 260; 50 S. W. 272.

29 Crook v. Gruell, 82 la. 736; 47 N. W. 1081.

30Chilstrom v. Eppinger, 127 Cal. 326; 78 Am. St. Rep. 46; 59 Pac. 696.

31 Redmond v. Staton, 116 N. C. 140; 21 S. E. 186.

32 Roberts v. Jacks, 31 Ark. 597; 25 Am. Rep. 584; Lovett v. Brown, 40 N. H. 511; Dewing v. Hutton, 40 W. Va. 521; 21 S. E. 780. Contra, Coit v. Waples, 1 Minn. 134; Woodland Co. v. Mendenhall, 82 Minn. 483; 85 N. W. 164.

33 Vendor's lien. Gessner v. Pal-mateer, 89 Cal. 89; 13 L. R. A. 187; 24 Pac. 608; 26 Pac. 789; Lagow v. Badollet, 1 Blackf. (Ind.) 416; 12 Am. Dec. 258; Douglass v. Blount, 95 Tex. 369; 58 L. R. A. 699; 67 S. W. 484; Schmertz v. Hammond, 47 W. Va. 527; 35 S. E. 945. Contra, that a vendor's lien is personal, and therefore, being non-assignable, does not pass by assignment of the purchase money. Elder v. Jones, 85 I11. 384; Law v. Butler, 44 Minn. 482; 9 L. R. A. 856; 47 N. W. 53; Hammond v. Peyton, 34 Minn. 529; 27 N. W. 72.

34 Carlton v. Buckner, 28 Ark. 66.

35 The Sarah J. Weed, 2 Lowell (U. S.) 555.

36 The William M. Hoag, 69 Fed. 742.

37 The Shrewsbury, 69 Fed. 1017.

38 Lien of livery stable keeper. Glascock v. Lemp, 26 Ind. App. 175.

59 N. E. 342. Contra, McPherson First National Bank v. Commission Co., 61 Mo. App. 143.

39 Lieu of attorney. Sibley v. Pine County, 31 Minn. 201; 17 N. W. 337.

40 Davis v. Bilsland, 18 Wall. (U. S.) 659; Duncan v. Hawn, 104 Cal. 10; 37 Pac. 626; Sibley v. Pine County, 31 Minn. 201; 17 N. W. 337. Logging lien, Casey v. Ault, 4 Wash. 167; 29 Pac. 1048. Mechanic's lien. Davis v. Bilsland, 18 Wall. (U. S.) 659; Clarkson v. Louderback, 36 Fla. 660; 19 So. 887; Murphy v. Adams, 71 Me. 113; 36 Am. Rep. 299; Henry, etc., Co. v. Fisherdick, 37 Neb. 207; 55 N. W. 643; Iaege v. Bossieux, 15 Gratt. (Va.) 83; 76 Am. Dec. 189. Contra, that mechanics' liens cannot be assigned. Lovett v. Brown, 40 N. H. 511. So by statute. O'Connor v. Ry., 1ll Mo. 185; 20 S. W. 16. So before statute. First National Bank of Decorah v. Day, 52 la. 680; 3 N. W 728. Statutory lien for materials furnished for a boat. The Victorian No. 2, 26 Or. 194; 46 Am. St. Rep. 616; 41 Pac. 1103. Tax lien, Hart v. Tiernan, 59 Conn. 521; 21 Atl. 1007. Lien for assessments. Gill v. Dunham (Cal.), 34 Pac. 68. Lien on threshing machine to secure laborers' wages. Duncan v. Hawn, 104 Cal. 10; 37 Pac. 626.

41 Law. Paramore v. Nabers, 42 la. 659; Macomber v. Parker, 14 Pick. (Mass.) 497. Equity. Ober v. Gallagher. 93 U. S. 199; Payne v. Wilson, 74 N. Y. 348.

42 Lien for street paving. Rauer v. Fay, 110 Cal. 361; 42 Pac. 902.

43 Mechanics' lien. Leftwich Lumber Co. v. Savings Association, 104 Ala. 584; 18 So. 48; Kinney v. Ore Co., 58 Minn. 455; 49 Am. St. Rep. 528; 60 N. W. 23; Bank v. School Directors, 91 Wis. 596; 65 N. W. 368. Landlord's lien on crops. Ballard v. May field, 107 Ala. 396; 18 So. 29.

44 In re Campbell, 102 Fed. 686; Drennen v. Deposit Co., 115 Ala. 592; 66 Am. St. Rep. 72; 39 L. R. A. 623; 23 So. 164; Falconio v. Lar-sen, 31 Or. 137; 37 L. R. A. 254; 48 Pac. 703; Mcllhenny v. Binz, 80 Tex. 1: 26 Am. St. Rep. 705; 13 S-W. 655.